link to Talbot Project home page link to De Montfort University home page link to Glasgow University home page
Project Director: Professor Larry J Schaaf
 

Back to the letter search >

Result number 6 of 10:   < Back     Back to results list   Next >  

Document number: 6086
Date: 11 Jan 1848
Recipient: KEY Thomas Hewitt
Author: TALBOT William Henry Fox
Collection: British Library, London, Manuscripts - Fox Talbot Collection
Collection number historic: LA48-6
Last updated: 26th January 2015

Lacock Abbey, Chippenham
Professor Key
11 Jany /48

Dr Sir

I received one letter from you not long ago, forwarded from the Athenæum Club, <1> which I have no doubt is the letter you speak of –

I send you a copy of the Literary Gazette containing my reply to the Q. Review <2> – In this reply I was confined to noticing the points which had been especially attacked by the Reviewer, and I was obliged to treat them in a popular style, not at all as I would have done if I had been defending them before the Philological Society or any other body of scholars and competent judges –

The fact is, that if I had been aware of the villainy (I will use no lesser term) of some miscalled literary men, I would not have published this comparatively unimportant volume until after I had completed and published a work which I believe to be a really important one, on European philology and the state of ancient or I rather mean to say primæval Europe.

I was not aware of the danger I ran in publishing a desultory and rambling volume, viz. of being knocked down by a ruffian before I had time to open my mouth – After I have laid before the public the results of the researches I allude to, I will give him leave to say what he pleases. There is no end to the catalogue of my deficiencies in the Q. Review. Judge of their truth from the following – It is said that I have only a dictionary acquaintance, if so much, with German; that is of course, that I cannot read that language. This is said without proof, and without the least attempt at proof. Now the fact is, that for fully twenty five years I have quite [sic] familiar with German, reading it with nearly as much facility as English. The object of such a shameless accumulation [sic] of his passes my power of guessing – I was not aware that I had a personal enemy in the literary world or that a great Review would allow itself to be made the vehicle of private hostility.

Ld Brougham has written a treatise <3> on the pursuit of knowledge under difficulties – the greatest difficulties which beset the path of knowledge are caused by the conduct of literary men themselves (or calling themselves such). You will perhaps let me know whether the name of the Reviewer has been mentioned to you, and if so whether he is a person of any note in the literary world or not. Of this particular subject of etymology he certainly knows next to nothing

Believe me yours very truly
H. F. Talbot


Notes:

1. Athenaeum Club, Pall Mall, London: WHFT’s club; a gentleman’s club composed primarily of artists and scientists.

2. John Wilson Croker wrote a highly negative review of WHFT, English Etymologies (London: J. Murray, 1847), in Quarterly Review, v. 81, September 1847, pp. 500–525. WHFT replied to this review in ‘The Reviewer Reviewed’, The Literary Gazette and Journal of belles lettres, science and art, no. 1615, 1 January 1848, p. 3. - see Doc. No: 06078. John Wilson Croker (1780-1857), Irish-born, was a Tory MP from 1807 to 1832 and Secretary of the Admiralty from 1810 to 1830. As an author, he was noted for his virulent reviews in The Quarterly Review as much as for his 1831 edition of Boswell's Live of Johnson.

3. Henry Brougham, Baron of Brougham and Vaux (1778–1868), Lord Chancellor and founder of the Society for Diffusion of Useful Knowledge. Among his publications on the pursuits of knowledge were Objects, advantages, and pleasures of science (London : Baldwin and Cradock, 1831), which was republished in 1848.

Result number 6 of 10:   < Back     Back to results list   Next >