link to Talbot Project home page link to De Montfort University home page link to Glasgow University home page
Project Director: Professor Larry J Schaaf
 

Back to the letter search >

Result number 3 of 5:   < Back     Back to results list   Next >  

Document number: 8539
Date: 01 Apr 1862
Recipient: PLAYFAIR Lyon
Author: TALBOT William Henry Fox
Collection: Royal Photographic Society Coll, National Media Museum, Bradford
Collection number: 148(f)
Last updated: 12th December 2010

[draft]

April 1 / 62 –

Lyon Playfair –

I vy much regret my inability t comply wh yr wish, so vy kindly expressed, but I am unable to do so, for many reasns, some of wch I will mentn. I have not pd sufft atttn t th process of Phy (since the Exh of 51) to enable me t judge of the merits of th nums specns wch will now be brt forwd. Most of these will be accompd by a statemt of the process by wch they were made, & the award of a medal will in many cases depend upon the novelty of the process, or the difficulty of skill wth wch certain difficults have bn surmounted – & wch I could not make mysf master of the subjt without mch labour & industry It wd

It wd howvr Of such matters, on such points howvr, I shd not be a competent judge, for I have bn obliged now for sevl yrs to relinquish the reading of the Scientific jrnls in conqce of the large demands upon my time, wch original investigations require not having time

for I seldom read ^any of the scientific jnls my own expts leaving me little time to devote bestow on to other subjts

On occasns like the prest a gt no of persons are always sure to be disappted of an [illegible deletion] where they have by in the award of the jury medals

& their first impulse is natlly to protest agst the composn of the jury – As their exists a ^Rule printed & publd by the Commrs forbiddg an Exhbr to be a juror ^if any public complaint were made of its compstn it wd be vy difficult to find a any satisfactory reply. To say that the Commrs did not consider ^their this Rule of any partr importce wd I am afraid hardly be thought un= satisfactory

And ^moreover to say th truth, I am not quite shd feel a little reluctant to abandon my own chance of receivg a medal for the specns wch I propose to exhibit (photc Engravings): & which may proby be awarded to me, not certnly on acct of their excellence, for they are far from havg attained lay no claim ^to that eminence quality but on account of their being a first essay in an almost entirely new path field. Much importce might not attach to the receipt award of a medal, but the absence of such award wd be a thing to be regretted (K)

For these reasons & others wh wch I will not trouble y. I feel that myself unable to accept of the honorable office proposed for my acceptance of juror in the Internatl Exbn

Blve me Dr Sir Yrs

(K) ^More especly as Many medals will be given to exhrs chiefly French – for specns more or less similar to mine, almost all of wch are made by processes founded upon that wch I published.

[expanded version:]

April 1, 1862 –

Lyon Playfair –

I very much regret my inability to comply with your wish, so very kindly expressed, but I am unable to do so, for many reasons, some of which I will mention. I have not paid sufficient attention to the process of Photography (since the Great Exhibition of 1851) to enable me to judge of the merits of the numeous specimens which will now be brought forward. Most of these will be accompanied by a statement of the process by which they were made, and the award of a medal will in many cases depend upon the novelty of the process, or the difficulty of skill with which certain difficulties have been surmounted – and which I could not make myself master of the subject without much labour and industry. It would It would however Of such matters, on such points however, I should not be a competent judge, for I have been obliged now for several years to relinquish the reading of the Scientific journals in consequence of the large demands upon my time, which original investigations require not having time for I seldom read any of the scientific journals, my own experiments leaving me little time to devote bestow on to other subjects –

On occasions like the present a great number of persons are always sure to be disappointed of an [illegible deletion] where they have by in the award of the jury medals & their first impulse is naturally to protest against the composition of the jury – As there exists a Rule printed and published by the Commissioners forbidding an Exhibitor to be a juror if any public complaint were made of its composition it would be very difficult to find a any satisfactory reply. To say that the Commissioners did not consider their this Rule of any particular importance would I am afraid hardly be thought unsatisfactory.

And moreover to say the truth, I am not quite should feel a little reluctant to abandon my own chance of receiving a medal for the specimens which I propose to exhibit (photoglyphic Engravings) <1>: and which may probably be awarded to me, not certainly on account of their excellence, for they are far from having attained lay no claim to that eminence quality but on account of their being a first essay in an almost entirely new path field. Much importance might not attach to the receipt award of a medal, but the absence of such award would be a thing to be regretted. More especially as many medals will be given to exhibitors chiefly French – for specimens more or less similar to mine, almost all of which are made by processes founded upon that which I published.

For these reasons and others with which I will not trouble you I feel that myself unable to accept of the honorable office proposed for my acceptance of juror in the International Exhibition.

Believe me dear sir, yours


Notes:

1. WHFT did indeed win a Prize Medal in the International Exhibition of 1862 for ‘photographic engravings on copper & steel, produced by the action of light alone’. For an illustration of the commemorative medal see the frontis to Larry J Schaaf, Sun Pictures Catalogue Twelve: Talbot and Photogravure (New York: Hans P Kraus, Jr, 2003).

Result number 3 of 5:   < Back     Back to results list   Next >